Please read Catherine Davis' "After Time" and Dylan Thomas' "Do Not Go Gentle Into That Good Night" and answer the following questions. You may have noticed that Catherine Davis's poem is a sort of response to Dylan Thomas' poem. In addition to choosing the same poetic form, villanelle, what other clues does Davis provide her readers that she is responding to Dylan's poem? What is Davis saying about death and loss, and how does it compare to Thomas' perspective? Finally, since Bishop's poem is also about loss, how would you describe the position that the speaker in her poem takes? Is her tone more like, Thomas', Davis' or neither? Explain.